Standards · v4.0

Supplier Admission & Verification Standards

The bar a supplier must clear, expressed as a published weighted model rather than an opinion. Includes the red lines that end a review regardless of score — and the route a supplier has to challenge a finding.

DocumentAdmission & Verification Standards
Version4.0
OwnerHead of Verification
Appeals decided byPractice Lead

1 · The 100-point model

Each of the nine modules is scored, then weighted to a total of 100. Weights are published so a supplier can see exactly where it lost points — and so a buyer can re-weight them if their risk priorities differ.

Production capability & capacity
18
Quality system & certification authenticity
16
Financial resilience
14
Ownership transparency & control
12
Compliance & sanctions screening
12
Legal identity & licence validity
10
Export & trade record
10
ESG & labour practice
8

Litigation & reputation (module 9) carries no weight of its own. It acts as a modifier: confirmed adverse litigation applies a penalty to the modules most affected, rather than a flat deduction we could quietly tune.

2 · Tier thresholds

OutcomeScoreMeaning for the buyer
Verified Premium 90–100 Suitable for regulated categories, public procurement and long-term programmes. Re-check annually.
Verified Plus 80–89 Suitable for most programmes. Conditions, if any, are minor and dated.
Verified 70–79 Acceptable with normal commercial controls. Specific weaknesses are named in the report.
Qualified 60–69 Do not onboard without conditions. Every condition is written out with a closure date.
Not verified Below 60 We do not recommend onboarding. The report states what would have to change.

A tier is a summary, not the report. The report always governs, and a supplier at 78 with a specific strength may be more suitable for a given brief than one at 85.

3 · Red lines

A confirmed red line ends the review at Not verified regardless of score. These are not negotiable, not weightable, and not subject to buyer override.

R1

Forced labour or child labour

Confirmed finding, on site or in authoritative records.

R2

Fabricated or altered certification

A certificate that does not exist at the issuing body, or has been altered in scope, date or holder.

R3

Sanctions or denied-party match

On the entity, its controller, or a beneficial owner, under any list we screen.

R4

Entity does not legally exist

No matching registry record, revoked licence, or a Unified Social Credit Code that resolves to a different company.

R5

Undisclosed subcontracting of a safety-critical process

Observed on site where the buyer's specification or a regulation requires disclosure.

R6

Obstruction of an audit

Refusal of site access, refusal of private worker interviews combined with other major findings, or evidence of staged documentation.

A red line is reported to the commissioning buyer within 24 hours of confirmation, ahead of the full report.

4 · Validity & re-check triggers

4.1

Standard validity: 12 months

From the evidence date shown on the report. The badge stops resolving on expiry — no grace period, no paid extension.

4.2

Early expiry triggers

Ownership or legal-representative change; licence lapse or revocation; new enforcement or insolvency filing; confirmed major safety or labour incident; adverse media we judge material.

4.3

Monitoring

Optional subscription: USD 90 per supplier per year. Trigger alerts only — a re-report is a separate instruction.

4.4

Scope change

Adding a product category or a second site requires a new engagement. A verification covers what it says it covers, and no more.

5 · Lapse & revocation

5.1

Lapse

Automatic at the evidence date plus 12 months. No action required by either party.

5.2

Revocation

Where a red line emerges after issue, the verification is revoked, the badge is disabled, and the commissioning buyer is notified the same working day.

5.3

Public record

Lapsed and revoked verifications remain visible with their status. We do not delete a record because it became inconvenient.

6 · Appeals process

Any supplier subject to a finding may appeal. There is no fee, and an appeal cannot affect future commercial treatment of the supplier by us.

1

Lodge

Within 30 days of the finding, in writing, stating the finding disputed and the evidence relied on.

Day 0
2

Assign

Decided by the Practice Lead — never the analyst who produced the file. A second reviewer is appointed.

Day 1–2
3

Re-examine

The disputed finding is re-worked from source. New evidence supplied by the supplier is assessed on its own grade.

Up to 10 working days
4

Decide

Upheld, partially upheld, or rejected — with reasons. Where upheld, the report is corrected and reissued.

Written outcome

Second appeal

Available only on new evidence or a claimed procedural error. Heard by a panel including one member external to Business Verify.

Cost

Free at both stages. Charging a supplier to correct our own work would make the appeal meaningless.

Publication

Appeals lodged, upheld and rejected are reported in aggregate annually, including the ones we lost.

Appeals may be sent to leo@businessverify.cn. Buyers may also raise a concern about our conduct via legal@businessverify.cn.

7 · Version history

  • v4.0 — current. Nine modules, published weights, six red lines, formal appeals.
  • v3.2 — added R5 (undisclosed safety-critical subcontracting) after audit evidence.
  • v3.0 — introduced certificate authentication as a scored module rather than a check.
  • v2.1 — added ESG module and early-expiry triggers.
  • v1.0 — initial five-module model.

Standards changes are applied prospectively with notice. Reports are not re-scored against a newer model without the buyer being told.