What we did, how often we said no, how often we were wrong, and what we are changing. Published whether or not the numbers flatter us — that is the only version of this document worth issuing.
Both signatories are accountable for the accuracy of these figures. Figures in this prototype are illustrative and pending sign-off.
219 files combined a desk verification with a physical site visit. On-site audits were conducted in 14 provinces.
The 210 failures broke down as follows. A single file can trigger more than one red line; the primary reason is counted.
| Red line | Reason | Files | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| R2 | Fabricated or altered certification | 86 | 41.0% |
| R4 | Entity does not exist / licence revoked | 47 | 22.4% |
| R6 | Obstruction of an audit | 24 | 11.4% |
| R3 | Sanctions or denied-party match | 21 | 10.0% |
| R1 | Forced or child labour finding | 18 | 8.6% |
| R5 | Undisclosed safety-critical subcontracting | 14 | 6.6% |
The single most common reason we refuse a supplier is a certificate that does not exist at the issuing body. Not a missing certificate — a forged or altered one. It is why we authenticate rather than copy.
Concentration reflects China's manufacturing geography rather than our marketing reach. Where we have thin coverage, we say so.
Largest single buying account represented 19% of revenue — below the 25% disclosure threshold.
The numbers that matter most are the ones where we were wrong.
Lodged by suppliers. 6 upheld, 9 partially upheld, 26 rejected.
Files changed after appeal — 36.6% of appeals resulted in a change to the report.
Material factual corrections issued, all within the 5-working-day SLA.
Files delivered late. Fee refunded in full, per our own terms.
Where we were wrong: 4 of the 6 upheld appeals concerned capacity conclusions drawn from registered data without on-site triangulation. In 2026 we now flag any capacity conclusion above a materiality threshold as audit-recommended rather than stating it as verified.
All staff and auditors completed the annual independence attestation. No refusals.
Both resulted in recusal from the affected file and reassignment. Neither file was delayed beyond SLA.
Raised via the independence channel. Two unsubstantiated; one resulted in a process change around gift handling.
No listing, badge, placement, audit-travel or consultancy income from any assessed supplier.
Every site visit was performed by a salaried Business Verify auditor.
Largest single buying account, disclosed here as required above 15%.
This report covers the calendar year 2025. Figures in this prototype are illustrative placeholders pending internal sign-off and external assurance.
An independent firm examines our controls annually, including the conflict register and the data behind this report.